Reusing a Salvaged Door (Part I)

Alright, time to get crackin’ on this whole “posting about the house” thing. This is the mudroom. Well, this was the mudroom when we moved in to our 1900 house:


This is the first thing people see when  they come into our sweet little home. And I’ll be honest, it has not been pretty, like, ever. It isn’t particularly old– the man who renovated the home before we bought it added it, the bathroom, and the laundry room onto the back of the house (before that, someone had cut up our beautiful hallway and there was a bathroom there…). It’s a tiny little dark room with no windows, two (probably kind of oversized for the space) sconces, and it had some pretty awful avocado green trim when we moved in. We lived with it that way for two and a half years.

This spring, I finally worked up the energy to at least paint the trim and the bench that Peter had installed for our shoes and other outdoor miscellany. I tried a bunch of different grays and finally settled on a charcoal gray called English Tea Party by Valspar. So, as of Friday, September 19th, 2015, this was the mudroom in our house.


I love having a mudroom. I love having a place to take off muddy shoes and hang up dripping coats. I love having a place for Dixie to go when she is “hoarking” (as in, about to throw up, and yes, that’s sarcasm). (*Side note: that dog barfs a lot, but I have to give her credit where credit is due- she really tries to make it to the door.)

What I didn’t love was the dark pit of despair that was our mudroom.

Peter and I have gone back and forth on what to do with this room. One option, which we eventually tossed out, was adding a very small window where the sconce is next to the door. Ultimately, we decided cutting one hole in the house per year was probably enough (dining room window, I’m looking at you).

The second, and far more economical, option was putting in a glass-windowed door back there. It would, of course, let in lots of light and possibly look better from the outside than the other one had, anyway. There were some issues with this choice, of course. Our house has lovely, heavy outside doors on it. Four of them, to be exact. So we couldn’t just go buy a newly-made door at Lowe’s and expect it to fit. And we didn’t want to- we try to be as true-to-period as possible with the changes we make on this house. On top of the struggle to find one that would have the quality and style of an old door, the cost of having one custom made at a big box store would have been prohibitive.

This left us with the option of finding a salvaged door at an architectural salvage place. The only problem with that option is that this is kind of a short, squat door. So our odds of finding something made of wood, heavy, the correct thickness, and with at least one window in it were kind of low…

Enter the Heritage Alliance in Jonesborough, TN. According to their website, the Heritage Alliance “is dedicated to the preservation of the architectural, historical, and cultural heritage of our region and to providing educational experiences related to history and heritage for a wide range of audiences.” They have a warehouse which is open two Saturdays per month in the warmer months; here, they store and sell their collected donations of architectural salvage, including doors, windows, bannisters, signs, you name it. Peter and his students have done volunteer work and internships there for years. Two weeks ago, we went to find out if any of the windowed doors at the H.A. fit our measurements…and you guys, one did.

Pete went to pick it up on two weeks later (and forgot to take pictures of the awesome warehouse for the blog, but maybe someday, I’ll add some here). Isn’t she a beaut?


Okay, okay, so she had seen better days…but she fit the measurements enough (Peter needed to add two inches to the bottom, since she had been cut down, and take off about a quarter of an inch on the side), she had six windows (okay, so there were a few panes missing and the others had been painted), she was a solid wood, paneled door, and she even had the doorknob (or more importantly, a hole for a doorknob) in the right spot. We think she is probably 50 years old and was the door to a business, given the paint covering the windows. And in her messed up glory, she is allllll ours.

Our first step was to give the door a good scrub down with some bleach water. This was my job. Admittedly, my title when it comes to things like modifying doors to fit our old house is Scrubber of Things. Picker of Paint Color. High Priestess of Keeping the Toddler Away.

Point is, most of this post is about what Pete did to fix the door.

But I definitely did the scrubbing. And the watching of the toddler. AT THE SAME TIME.


(And I scrubbed down an old headboard Peter made to use in the guest room. Boom! Multitasking!)

Then Pete moved the door to the front porch and worked his Pete magic, which I shall now try to chronicle without accidentally lying about what he did. Many of these photos were taken through the window as I watched The Fantastic Mr. Fox with the Boy for the 14th time this month.

DSC_1281 DSC_1282

First, to close the gaps that had developed throughout the years, Pete clamped the pieces together and installed wooden pegs. These were later sawed off and when the door is painted, you’ll never know they were there.


Next, he installed a piece of wood along the bottom to make the door tall enough to fit our doorframe. He primed and I painted it the paprika color of the other doors on the house, just so it wouldn’t have to be done upside-down-like later.


The next part of the task was cutting the piece of glass he brought home from the warehouse. He did this by scoring it with a glass cutter and then snapping it off. He got three panes out of it (though he hoped to get four). Whew!

Then, Pete scraped out the old window glazing, placed the new panes in, and reglazed the windows with putty we bought at Lowe’s. It has to sit for a couple of weeks before I can paint the door, but the door was definitely ready to be placed in the door frame.

DSC_1286 DSC_1288

Out with the old door…


…and in with the new! All of this next part was done while the Boy napped in the next room. It’s amazing what kids can sleep through!

Pete had to do some mortising to make room on the new door for the larger (and fewer– it originally had three) hinges that were on the frame from the old door. I employed my considerable skill in holding things up with my foot while he screwed the door into place. Add Supreme Owner of the Foot that Holds Things to my list of titles.

A little cussing later, and we had a working doorknob, as well. I went with a really simple oil-rubbed bronze handle from Lowe’s. A part of me wanted to buy a reproduction double-cylinder lock set, but they’re pretty wickedly expensive and the whole point of this project was replacing the door on the cheap. Our old doorknob was a mortise doorknob and with the door’s existing hole, we couldn’t use it. So on went the new double-cylinder doorknob…



…and this is where we stand! There is light in the back of the house!

Next, I’ll be painting the door to match the trim, painting the outside the paprika accent color we chose for the rest of the doors, and finding a curtain solution so we don’t treat our neighbors to awkward moments as we leave the restroom in the evening.

Thanks for checking in with my first actual, real-life, doing things post on this blog! If you have friends who are interested in old homes, historical maintenance, renovation, restoration, do-it-yourself, reading stuff from someone whose husband does the real work and she picks the paint colors, or anything along those lines, feel free to share the blog with them!